Discover
When I first booted up Top Spin's latest installment, I'll admit my expectations were sky-high. As someone who's spent probably too many hours across various sports simulations, from FIFA's Career Mode to NBA 2K's sprawling neighborhood, I approached this tennis revival with genuine excitement. What I discovered, however, was a game that feels simultaneously polished in its core mechanics yet surprisingly incomplete in its offerings. The options outside of MyCareer are extremely barebones, and this limitation becomes apparent within just a few hours of playtime. It's somewhat understandable for what effectively amounts to a fresh launch for the Top Spin series after nearly a decade's absence, but the contrast becomes stark when you consider how other sports titles have evolved during that same period.
I remember specifically thinking about NBA 2K24, which I'd been playing just before diving into Top Spin. That game offers at least seven distinct major modes beyond its career equivalent, including MyTeam, MyNBA, The W, and various online competitive formats. Meanwhile, Top Spin's local play options are limited to single and doubles exhibition games, plus the Top Spin Academy tutorials. Don't get me wrong - the Academy itself is wonderfully presented, with tennis legend John McEnroe's narration adding genuine credibility to the experience. His voice guides you through the fundamentals with that trademark intensity we associate with the former champion, and for newcomers to tennis games, it's probably the best tutorial system I've encountered in years. The problem is, once you've completed its approximately 45-minute curriculum (I timed it at 43 minutes during my playthrough), there's little reason to return unless you're introducing the game to a friend.
What strikes me as particularly interesting is how this limited scope affects long-term engagement. In my first week with the game, I probably logged around 15 hours in MyCareer mode, developing my custom player from a rookie to someone who could reasonably compete in minor tournaments. But after that initial burst, the repetition began to set in. Without additional modes to break up the monotony, I found myself taking longer breaks between sessions. Compare this to something like WWE 2K23, which offers multiple distinct single-player experiences alongside its career mode, and Top Spin starts to feel like it's missing crucial components that modern sports gamers have come to expect.
The exhibition matches themselves are solid - the core tennis gameplay is arguably the best the series has ever delivered - but they lack the contextual meaning that modes like tournaments or career scenarios provide. I can play Roger Federer against Serena Williams in a fantasy match, which is fun for about twenty minutes, but without stakes or progression systems, the experience feels hollow. I've probably played around 30 exhibition matches total, and while the core mechanics remain satisfying, the lack of surrounding structure makes these matches feel more like practice sessions than meaningful competitions.
From a development perspective, I understand the challenges here. Building a sports game from the ground up after such a long hiatus means prioritizing certain elements over others, and the developers clearly focused on nailing the core tennis experience first. The ball physics, player movement, and shot variety are all exceptional - significantly improved over Top Spin 4's already impressive foundation. But in 2023, with sports games routinely offering hundreds of hours of varied content, launching with what feels like a skeleton of modes is a risky proposition. I've noticed that among my gaming circles, the conversation around Top Spin has already shifted from "this plays great" to "I wish there was more to do."
The online components don't substantially expand the offerings either. While I've enjoyed my ranked matches (I've played about 25 of them with a roughly 60% win rate), the online infrastructure feels similarly limited compared to contemporaries. There's no equivalent to FIFA's Ultimate Team or NBA 2K's MyTeam, both of which have become massive revenue drivers for their respective publishers while providing near-endless engagement loops for dedicated players. I've spent probably 200 hours in FIFA's Ultimate Team alone this year, and while that model has its controversies, its absence in Top Spin leaves a noticeable void in long-term motivation.
What's fascinating is how this limited scope affects different types of players. For casual tennis fans who might play a few matches here and there, the current offering might be perfectly adequate. But for the dedicated sports gamer - the type who sinks hundreds of hours into their favorite titles - the content drought becomes apparent quickly. I fall somewhere in the middle, and after about 35 total hours with Top Spin, I'm already feeling the pull to return to other, more feature-rich sports titles despite preferring tennis as a sport.
There's also the question of value proposition. At a standard $69.99 launch price, Top Spin asks the same as games offering substantially more content. While the core gameplay justifies much of that cost for tennis purists, more casual players might balk at the limited modes. I've personally gotten my money's worth thanks to my enjoyment of the core mechanics, but I completely understand why some reviewers have highlighted the lack of content as a significant drawback.
Looking forward, I'm hopeful that future updates or sequels will expand on this solid foundation. The developers have proven they can deliver exceptional tennis gameplay - now they need to build the ecosystem around it. Additional modes like historical tournaments, more elaborate career scenarios, or creative online competitions could transform Top Spin from a great tennis simulator into an essential sports package. For now, what we have is a fantastic core experience in desperate need of more reasons to keep playing. It's like having a perfectly maintained tennis court with only one type of tournament available - the fundamentals are excellent, but variety would make it truly special.